Letters to the Editor

A public discussion about proportional representation is needed.

Dear Editor,

MLA (and friend) Jackie Tegart’s opinion piece on proportional representation (The Journal, November 9, 2017) is a useful contribution to an essential province-wide debate.

I agree with Jackie that our democratic system should be “built upon the idea that everyone’s voice is equal.” But our current system does not meet this test; it generally results in majority governments elected by a minority of voters.

Jackie’s colleague Andrew Wilkinson complains that the 1996 B.C. election was “stolen” because the NDP got 39 seats with 40 per cent of the votes, and the Liberals, with 42 per cent of the votes, got only 33 seats. In the next election in 2001, the Liberals proposed electoral reform in their campaign. They got 57 per cent of the vote and 97 per cent of the seats (no complaints from Andrew about that one). The last Canadian majority government with a majority of votes was in 1984. That’s first-past-the-post for you: far from “everyone’s voice is equal”.

Jackie says “The 2.8 million people living in the Lower Mainland would have a disproportionate amount of representation and control over the entire province.” There is no basis at all for this statement. Our current system makes up for this by providing for fewer voters per MLA in rural regions (for instance, Jackie was elected by 6,597 voters here in Fraser-Nicola, while it took 14,101 votes to elect her colleague Tracey Redies in Surrey-White Rock). A PR system would have similar adjustments.

Jackie is right that “PR systems often lead to smaller parties and encourage coalition governments.” PR is designed to do just that: to ensure that smaller voices get heard. That is why some form of PR is used by 29 of the world’s 35 major democracies. But to suggest that this means that “government will likely grind to an indefinite gridlock with no one at the helm” is absurd. How about Germany? Japan? Norway? Australia? And what about the gridlock for the last nine years in the good old first-past-the-post USA?

Jackie is right as well that the form of question is critical. The 2005 referendum (on a relatively complicated form of PR) was approved by 57 per cent of the popular vote across the province (the same percentage of the vote that had elected a government with 97 per cent of the seats), with majority support in 77 of 79 ridings. In 2009, a deliberately ambiguous and confusing question was designed by the Liberal cabinet, and got only 39 per cent support. We must insist that the ballot question in this case is completely clear, that the facts on all sides are readily available, and that we have ample opportunity for debate.

Finally, along with Jackie, “I encourage you all to watch for further information, as this is a vote that could change B.C. forever.” This is about the future of our democracy, after all. We should all be engaged. To that end, I volunteer to have a public discussion with Jackie on this most important topic, to be held here in Ashcroft, the time and place to be at our busy MLA’s convenience.

John Kidder

Ashcroft, B.C.



editorial@accjournal.ca

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Just Posted

Local Indigenous model gets opportunity to be on the runway in major Australian fashion show

Jada Raphael of the Cook’s Ferry Band will represent the Nlakapamux and Secwepemc Nations.

New members help keep Ashcroft and District Lions Club in good shape

Other Lions clubs are having to close because of aging membership and lack of new members.

Please don’t feed the deer: you’ll do more harm than good

Plus the possibility of wolves in Ashcroft, why we feed the birds, and why you don’t want raccoons.

Local News Briefs: Night Market and Swap and Shop coming to the HUB in February

Plus Experience Gold Country, why not to turn on house lights while driving, and more.

Golden Country: Yale goes from deserted Hudson’s Bay Company post to boom town

When gold fever prompted thousands of miners north, Yale found itself at the eye of the storm.

B.C. boy denied $19,000-per-month drug to ease ‘crippling pain’ for 3rd time

Sooke mom Jillian Lanthier says son Landen Alexa has been forgotten about by Premier John Horgan

Senior randomly stabbed in B.C. mall food court

Woman arrested after victim, 71, suffers serious injuries

B.C. Liberal hopefuls begin final leadership push

Five MLAs, one outsider pitch policies to party members

Vancouver Island marijuana producer bought by Aphria in $230M deal

Aphria’s annual production forecast increases to 230,000 kgs

UPDATED: ‘Young, innocent’ teen hit during Vancouver shootout dies

15-year-old Coquitlam boy was in a car driving by the scene

Ontario man charged with selling Canadian’s usernames and passwords

Ontario man ran site that peddled billions of pieces of personal data: RCMP

Video: B.C. documentary features Okanagan ice climbing

First documentary for Penticton filmmaker captures elusive Okanagan ice climbing

David Emerson quits lumber talks as legal action begins

Former federal minister served as B.C. softwood trade point man

Men accused in Michael Bonin’s murder knew him: IHIT

20-year-old’s body found on a rural service road North of Hope in April

Most Read