Writer concerned about Proportional Representation set-up

Huge ridings will give large urban communities advantage over smaller rural ridings

Dear Editor,

The current referendum on Proportional Representation (PR) is not something that should be taken lightly.

In time, both systems filter out parties that gain the majority.

First past the post (FPTP) systems, given enough time will eventually end up with a system where two parties dominate the landscape and switch back and forth as the dominant party from election to election.

In Canada, the Liberals, Conservatives and the NDP dominate most of the electoral landscape.

Proportional Representation systems, given enough time will eventually end up with a multiple party system where fringe parties gain dominance.

In the European Union, almost every country uses PR.

What is happening there is the mainstream parties are losing ground rapidly and extreme right wing parties are gaining ground rapidly; these include anti-immigration parties, racist parties, and even Neo-Nazi leaning parties that use differing party names.

This is largely due to instability in government, fallout from the 2008 financial crash, and the high unemployment that resulted. In every European state that uses pro rep in Europe, there are today Neo Nazi parties sitting in their parliaments.

Adopting a proportional representation electoral system in BC would potentially open the doors of the legislature to far-right politicians, just like what is happening in the European Union.

The NDP party is a left leaning party, so, in fact, they are trying to create a voting system that in the long run could lead to their demise if far right politicians gain voter support at some time in the future.

The most important concern that most people should have about the proportional representation referendum is the way that it is being conducted.

At least one court case is contesting this. Unfortunately, it will not be heard until after the referendum is completed, due to a high case load at the Supreme Court of B.C.

In 2009, a referendum was done at the same time as the provincial election and was a part of the electoral ballot.

The referendum would have required 60 per cent overall approval and 50 per cent approval in at least 60 per cent (51 out of 85) of the province’s electoral districts in order to succeed. However, the province’s voters defeated the change with only 39.09 per cent of 1,651,139 votes in favour of change (representing a 55 per cent voter turnout).

This referendum is not by riding, rather it is by every valid returned vote in the province.

This gives the population of Greater Vancouver a huge advantage over the population of the rural ridings.

It has been estimated that in rural ridings that 70 per cent up to 90 per cent of the mailed in ballots must vote against PR just to balance out this serious population disparity.

The referendum, if allowed to proceed as determined, offends several core values grounding section 3 of the Canadian charter of rights. One being equality of voting power of which the courts have described as fundamental to the Canadian concept of democracy. (See page 16 of the Dixon decision)

One thing that is missing from the information that is needed to make an informed decision is the fact that the size of the new ridings could be huge. This will be decided after the referendum?

This effectively means your local MLA office will be closed and the new MLAs may not even live in your area.

The second thing to make note of is the claim that another referendum will be held after two general elections to see if B.C. wants to keep the new voting system or go back to using First Past the Post.

The fact is one government cannot bind the future action of a future government. Government, including this one, can amend the legislation they passed last year and change it, never mind a new government after the next election. So, a new referendum may never happen, actually?

It is expected that the voter response will be low, and if this happens, only 15 per cent of the registered voters could decide how we vote moving forward.

Therefore, now is not the time to not vote because you are happy with the current voting system! During this referendum – the voters that are happy with the current system must pay heed to the fact that their votes are needed to keep the voting system the same as it is.

Glenn Martin


Just Posted

RCMP looks for tips after break-in at School District 74 works yard

Thieves cut locks into the compound overnight on Dec. 12 and stolle two drills

TNRD recycling workshop answers a lot of questions

Residents learned about changes to recycling, a planned new Eco-depot in the area, and more

Winning Aboriginal Enterprises team from 1990 gets back together on the ice

Team members reconvened to play again, and make a touching presentation to Leslie Edmonds

2018 in review part one: Economic impact of 2017 wildfires more than $30 million in region

Plus success for a local model, a poster controversy, a new doctor, and much more.

Cache Creek mayor Santo Talarico stresses need for collaboration

‘If the area is a success, Cache Creek will be a success’

Man caught on camera allegedly trying to defraud ICBC

Auto-insurer warns B.C. drivers to record info after crashes

‘People talk about deep sadness:’ Scientists study climate change grief

Some call it environmental grief, some call it solastalgia — a word coined for a feeling of homesickness when home changes around you.

As protectors abandon Trump, investigation draws closer

Cohen was sentenced Wednesday to three years in prison for an array of crimes.

Senate delays start of sittings in new home, delaying start of broadcasts

The Senate and House of Commons are moving into temporary homes for the next decade as a result of long-planned and badly needed renovations to the Centre Block.

UK leader seeks EU lifeline after surviving confidence vote

EU leaders gather for a two-day summit, beginning Thursday, which will center on the Brexit negotiations.

French police try to catch attack suspect dead or alive

Local authorities increase death toll to three, including 13 wounded and five in serious condition

BCHL’ers blanked by Russia at World Junior A Challenge

Canada West loses battle of the unbeaten teams in the preliminary round

Second Canadian missing in China after questioning by authorities

Michael Spavor, founder of a non-profit that organizes cultural-exchange trips to North Korea, “is presently missing in China”

Cannabis gift ideas for this holiday season

Put the green in happy holidays, now that cannabis is legal in Canada

Most Read